Customer Service: 1-800-94-HONEY

Butt Plugs

From beginner’s butt plugs to advanced butt plugs and even giant butt plugs, our huge range of anal sex toys have real customer reviews and detailed size info to help you find the best butt plug for you. With free shipping with every purchase.

Category: Butt Plugs

    • Beginners Basic Slimline Butt Buddy Butt Plug
    • Beginners Basic Slimline Butt Buddy Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 9/10(169 reviews)
    • Beautifully small, beautifully formed and beautifully BASIC! This Slimline Butt Buddy is ideal for beginners or those who want an easy-to-use butt plug which sits comfortably for hour after pleasurable hour!
    • Our Price: $12.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Tracey Cox Supersex Beginner's Butt Plug
    • Tracey Cox Supersex Beginner's Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 8/10(13 reviews)
    • If you're starting out with anal play, this beginner's butt plug from the Tracey Cox range is perfect for you. Made from soft and flexible silicone, this mini butt plug is great if you're looking to explore a whole new range of orgasmic sensations.
    • Get Bondage Tape worth $9.99 when you buy two Tracey Cox products
    • Our Price: $16.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Tailbud Stainless Steel Tail Butt Plug
    • Tailbud Stainless Steel Tail Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 10/10(4 reviews)
    • More than just a tail butt plug, this stunning handmade steel toy is anal jewellery that will turn your body into a work of art!
    • Our Price: $144.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Basix Mini Butt Plug
    • Basix Mini Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 9/10(22 reviews)
    • Small yet perfectly formed, this cute, flexible plug has a super slim shaft that widens very, very gently, making it perfect for beginners. Funky colours, skin-safe rubber, great price!
    • Our Price: $10.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Doc Johnson Large Black Butt Plug
    • Doc Johnson Large Black Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 8/10(35 reviews)
    • High-quality black Doc Johnson butt plug - total satisfaction from the world-famous brand. Approx 7 inches circumference at its widest.
    • Our Price: $16.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Fun Factory Bootie Butt Plug
    • Fun Factory Bootie Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 9/10(55 reviews)
    • This velvety-soft Bootie Butt Plug is the perfect anal toy for those experimenting in the pleasures of anal stimulation or looking to add something special to your collection. Soft and flexible yet hard enough to arouse the posterior passion zones.
    • Our Price: $31.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Xtra Large Butt Plug
    • Xtra Large Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 9/10(27 reviews)
    • High-quality American-made butt plug - so good you can feel the difference. Approx 8.5 inches circumference at its widest.
    • Our Price: $23.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Doc Johnson Classic Medium Butt Plug
    • Doc Johnson Classic Medium Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 9/10(9 reviews)
    • High-quality American-made butt plug - so good you can feel the difference. Approx 5.25 inches circumference at its widest.
    • Our Price: $13.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Doc Johnson Medium Pony Tail Butt Plug
    • Doc Johnson Medium Pony Tail Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 8/10(9 reviews)
    • Yee haw! Top quality medium pony tail butt plug from Doc Johnson, with a full tassled tail. Gently rounded tip, flared base. Made of soft, flexible PVC.
    • Our Price: $39.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • 3 Bangs For Your Butt Mega Dildo
    • 3 Bangs For Your Butt Mega Dildo

    • Average Review: 10/10(17 reviews)
    • Wham, bam, thank you, ma'am - or should that be sir? Either way, this colossal, three-headed monster dildo is begging to plunder your love cave. Are you up to the challenge? When we say mega, we mean Large Dildo with a capital L D.
    • Our Price: $72.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Rosebud Stainless Steel Large Butt Plug
    • Rosebud Stainless Steel Large Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 9/10(6 reviews)
    • More than just a butt plug, this stunning handmade steel sex toy is anal jewellery that will turn your body into a work of art! A lovely silver butt plug that you will cherish.
    • Our Price: $112.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Small Penis Butt Plug
    • Small Penis Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 8/10(3 reviews)
    • Anal pleasure from a realistic dinky penis butt plug with flared base. Made from strong rubber, the realistic cock will please you from behind time after time. Simple satisfaction at a great price. Good for first-timers.
    • Our Price: $14.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Tantus Ripple Silicone Small Butt Plug
    • Tantus Ripple Silicone Small Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 8/10(1 review)
    • A great size for those discovering the pleasures of anal sex for the first time, this top-quality silicone plug is rippled too. Completely flexible, harness compatible, the 4 graduated beads start at .5 of an inch in diameter and go up to 1.0 inches.
    • Our Price: $29.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Amorous Beginner's Curved Comfort Butt Plug
    • Amorous Beginner's Curved Comfort Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 10/10(1 review)
    • This beautiful unisex silicone butt plug is ideal for first time anal play. Measuring just 3.5 inches in length with a maximum girth of 3.85 inches, it's beautifully sloped with stimulating nodules that feel incredible, especially against the prostate.
    • Our Price: $19.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Doc Johnson Mood Naughty Small Silicone Butt Plug
    • Doc Johnson Mood Naughty Small Silicone Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 8/10(1 review)
    • Perfectly formed and manageable in size, this small butt plug is ideal for anal sex toy beginners. Made from smooth silicone, this plug slides in effortlessly and anchors securely outside the body, so you can enjoy anal stimulation completely worry-free.
    • Our Price: $25.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Liquorice Dip Butt Plug Triple Pack
    • Liquorice Dip Butt Plug Triple Pack

    • Average Review: 8/10(47 reviews)
    • How's this for a pocket-friendly butt plug triple pack? A small, medium and large butt plug, each made from quality firm-but-flexible jelly and with suction cups for sticking to smooth surfaces for hands-free fun.
    • Our Price: $27.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Lovehoney Booty Buddy Silicone Butt Plug
    • Lovehoney Booty Buddy Silicone Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 9/10(57 reviews)
    • A silicone butt plug that's smooth, easy to insert and both comfortable and stimulating to wear. Ideal for men and women, this flexible butt plug is ergonomically designed to massage your erogenous zones during sex, masturbation or when worn all day.
    • Our Price: $15.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Cupid's Itty Bitty Beginner's Butt Plug
    • Cupid's Itty Bitty Beginner's Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 9/10(34 reviews)
    • A small, smooth, unintimidating butt plug that's perfect for beginners or advanced users who want a plug they can wear all day! Skin friendly silicone is safe to use internally and externally and also allows for easy cleaning and optimum hygiene.
    • Our Price: $14.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Doc Johnson Medium Black Butt Plug
    • Doc Johnson Medium Black Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 8/10(18 reviews)
    • Made from skin safe rubber measuring 5 inches in girth and 4.6 inches in insertable length, this medium-sized butt plug is ideal for anal sex beginners looking to move onto bigger anal sex toys or for advanced anal players warming up for bigger toys.
    • Our Price: $16.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Lovehoney Starter Orgasmic Glass Butt Plug
    • Lovehoney Starter Orgasmic Glass Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 8/10(41 reviews)
    • If you're already into anal sex or butt plugs, then moving onto more solid anal sex toys is your next step on the pathway to pleasure. Smooth and sturdy, this glass butt plug has a gently rounded tip and measures just 2 inches in girth.
    • Our Price: $30.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Tracey Cox Supersex Advanced Anal Butt Plug Kit
    • Tracey Cox Supersex Advanced Anal Butt Plug Kit

    • Average Review: 9/10(20 reviews)
    • A step up from the original, the Advanced Anal Kit has been developed by sex expert Tracey Cox, to give you the best sensations yet! Contains a guide to anal sex and a large and medium butt plug with a special secret compartment to add some extra thrills!
    • Get Bondage Tape worth $9.99 when you buy two Tracey Cox products
    • Our Price: $26.99
    • Sorry, out of stock
    • Large Penis Butt Plug
    • Large Penis Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 9/10(17 reviews)
    • Anal pleasure from a realistic penis butt plug with flared base. Made from strong rubber, the realistic cock will please you from behind time after time. Simple satisfaction at a great price.
    • Our Price: $17.99
    • Sorry, out of stock
    • Medium Penis Butt Plug
    • Medium Penis Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 9/10(18 reviews)
    • Enjoy ultimate anal pleasure from a realistic penis butt plug with flared base. Made from strong rubber, the realistic cock will please you from behind time after time. Simple satisfaction at a great price.
    • Our Price: $15.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Crystal Clear Rainbow Butt Plug
    • Crystal Clear Rainbow Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 9/10(12 reviews)
    • Stunning, ultra-soft crystal clear plug with extremely cool rainbow-coloured core. So nice you might want to have one for the bedroom and one for the mantlepiece. Wouldn't look out of place in an aquarium, either...
    • Our Price: $19.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Doc Johnson Super Slim Butt Plug Small
    • Doc Johnson Super Slim Butt Plug Small

    • Average Review: 9/10(10 reviews)
    • Absolutely perfect if you're looking to discover the joys of anal sex for the first time, our smallest butt plug is gently rounded at the tip, super smooth and really flexible. Load up on the lube and prepare for fun!
    • Our Price: $19.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Doc Johnson Small Black Butt Plug
    • Doc Johnson Small Black Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 7/10(5 reviews)
    • High-quality Doc Johnson butt-plug - the famous brand delivers satisfaction world-wide. Approx 3.5 inches circumference at its widest.
    • Our Price: $11.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • Doc Johnson Juli Ashton's Anal Beginner's Butt Plug Kit
    • Doc Johnson Juli Ashton's Anal Beginner's Butt Plug Kit

    • Average Review: 9/10(10 reviews)
    • It's only going to be The Best Night In Ever! Juli's sexy anal kit includes 3 different sized, top quality, soft butt plugs, a super-smooth multispeed vibrator (suitable for all pleasure points!) and water-based lube for extra-orgasmic entry.
    • Our Price: $43.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery
    • X Large Triple Bump Butt Plug
    • X Large Triple Bump Butt Plug

    • Average Review: 8/10(21 reviews)
    • Triple bumps for triple pleasure! A solid rubber butt plug for deep, fulfilling anal play. Load up on the lube and see if you can take inch after satisfying inch.
    • Our Price: $27.99
    • In stock
    • Free Delivery