10 Best Butt Plugs For Every Body

Everyone has a butt and butt plugs are a great way to explore this universal erogenous zone. Learn how to explore the excitement of anal play with our list of the top 10 best butt plugs around.

Why Buy a Butt Plug?

Oh, let us count the wonderful ways. We actually wrote an entire blog post about why people use butt plugs, but here's a quick rundown:

  • Anal play has the potential to feel good to anyone. No matter what other parts you have, you have a butt full of nerve endings just waiting to be satisfied.
  • If you have a vulva, you might be excited to know that direct stimulation to the anus can stimulate the vagina. This is all thanks to the pudental nerve, better known as your perineum or taint.
  • There are plenty of anal plugs to try! Textured, vibrating, glass, metal - each brings different sensations all their own for you to enjoy. Experiment and find your favourite.
  • Put simply, anal plugs can enhance and amplify your orgasms. Wearing a butt plug while enjoying other sex acts, like oral, masturbation or vaginal sex, has the potential to seriously boost your pleasure.

How to Choose a Butt Plug

Choosing a butt plug doesn't have to be intimidating. There are plenty of options out there, so start by looking at what excites you and measuring it against your experience level. If you've never done any anal play before, choose a small butt plug like those in our selection of beginners butt plugs. As a rule of thumb, aim for toys that gradually increase in size and always start small.

Before you start a play session, be sure to load up on the water-based anal lube. Water-based lube is compatible with all sex toys, and anal lube is specifically formulated to provide long-lasting cushioning. Your ass does not self-lubricate, so lube is always a must.

Even once you're an advanced anal player and enjoyer of anal toys, it's important to always listen to your body and go at your own pace. Check the ingredients and avoid using lubricants with numbing agents, as these can interfere with you knowing your body's limits.

Our Picks: The Best Anal Plugs

Best Butt Plugs for newbies

Lovehoney Butt Tingler 10 Function Vibrating Butt Plug 3.5 Inch
(610)
$13.99 $26.99 You save: $13.00 (48%)

Good smooth vibes are yours with this petite plug. Slender in size, this plug is an ideal choice for newbies. A point to note about vibrating butt plugs is that they can be enjoyed switched on or off - it's almost like having a two-for-one toy. If you find the vibrations are a bit much when you're still coming to grips with anal, turn them off until you're ready to do more experimenting.

What customers say: "My partner (female) and I (male) got this as we were both interested in trying anal play. We are very sexually active, although we've never tried using toys until we got this! We both really love the vibration strength and patterns, and I as a male can say I really enjoyed feeling the vibrations against my prostate which I wasn't expecting. I would even be tempted to use this now if I was masturbating on my own."

Buy it here

Lovehoney Extra Petite Beginner Butt Plug

Lovehoney Classic Silicone Extra Petite Beginner's Butt Plug
(75)
$14.99

The most cautious among us can benefit from this teeny tiny butt plug as their intro to anal play. No bigger than the average pinky, this plug is a perfect first step that practically guarantees a good experience.

What customers say: "It was a good introduction to the world of butt plugs. Easy to use, pleasurable and did the trick. Good value for money and a good investment if it is something you are 'trying out' before spending more money. It got me hooked and I have purchased a variety of plugs since. It really helped with reaching climax and felt very pleasurable."

Buy it here

Lovehoney Jeweled Heart Aluminum Plug

Lovehoney Jeweled Heart Metal Butt Plug 2.5 Inch
(227)
$18.99 $26.99 You save: $8.00 (30%)

Try adding a little sparkle to your starter butt plug adventures with this weighty metal plug. Some people find the smoothness of metal feels even better than silicone, and the added weight makes it ideal for wear during vaginal sex.

What customers say: "I bought this as the first anal toy I’ve ever used. I found it to be really comfortable for first time use with lube, big enough to be satisfying but small enough that it was comfortable to wear for a good period of time. Added bonus of it looking super cute, felt like it ‘prettied up’ an area that is not always the prettiest. I like that it’s metal too as the cold is an added sensation."

Buy it here

Best Plug for couples

We-Vibe Vector

We-Vibe Vector+ App and Remote Controlled Rechargeable Prostate Massager
(106)
$139.00

The We-Vibe Vector is a long-standing favorite of many anal adventurers thanks to its adjustable angle, and with the Vector's upgrade to its remote, there's no better butt toy for couples. It can even be used long-distance thanks to the super convenient, long-distance loving We-Vibe app.

What customers say: "The adjustable bulb makes finding the perfect spot super easy and believe me you immediately know if that's the right spot as soon as you turn it on because if it is there's no holding back. I absolutely love the toy and my partner loves using it on me. It has changed my sex life and made me more open and excited for more anal play."

Buy it here

Best sets for anal training

Lovehoney Jeweled Metal Butt Plug Set (3 Piece)
(50)
$59.99

Weighty and wondrous, this set of 3 metal butt plugs is perfect for getting started with progressive anal play. The graduated sizes make it easy to start small and go large, while the metal construction is perfect for enjoying a little temperature play.

What customers say: "This is probably the best plug or set thereof that we have ever put our hands on. Really well fabricated, with no mould lines or any imperfections; these are a really high quality product worth their weight (which is a lot for the big boy!). There is a nice variety of size with these, which is important obviously because they have n give in their structure but the small size is perfect for beginners and the large is not too horrendous for a brave adventurer to attempt."

Buy it here

Lovehoney Anal Toy Kit

Lovehoney Bumper Booty Bundle Anal Sex Toy Kit (6 Piece)
(121)
$64.99

When you're ready to try a little bit of everything, look no further than this kit. Home to 2 x butt plugs, anal beads, a prostate massager, an anal douche and a bullet vibe, it invites you to try out several different sensations so you can find your fave.

What customers say: "I'm new to sex toys and anal play, but this kit is a good start. The included douche was a good for reducing some anxieties I had about anal. The best toys for my prostate have been the larger plug and the anal beads."

Buy it here

Lovehoney Jeweled Silicone Butt Plug Set
(22)
$54.99

Get ready to rock your rump with this jewelled silicone butt plug set. Featuring three tush-pleasing plugs, in small, medium and large, these blinged-out bad boys look good and feel even better. Pair with water-based lube for indulgent anal satisfaction.

What customers say: "As someone who has been interested in anal play for a while I found these less intimidating than other products and very pretty. They are easy to clean and look great, the small one fits in easily and after a while I found the medium fits well too. I found putting a wand onto the base makes for some amazing feelings during playtime!"

Buy it here

Best plugs for prostate owners

Lovehoney Sensual Glass Booty Buddy Butt Plug
(16)

Smooth, curved and irresistibly sleek, the Booty Buddy is perfect for P-spot play and firm anal stimulation, with its flared T-bar base giving you complete comfort during wear. Crafted from firm borosilicate glass, it's perfect for firm internal pressure, sized to suit newbies and, if we may say so, looks pretty darn fine, too.

What customers say: "I love glass because of the ease of cleaning and the feel. The way this curves and the bump on the end... The shape was a little concerning looking at it online but OMG if you are looking at plugs and have a prostate, buy this NOW"

Buy it here

Lovehoney Cock Ring and Butt Plug

Lovehoney Inside Job Silicone Cock Ring and Butt Plug
(167)
$24.99

Prostates and penises are usually a package deal, so give yourself the gift of thrilling prostate stimulation with the benefits of an attached cock ring.

What customers say: "At last, a plug that doesn't fall out! The plug is bigger than most beginners' plugs but the beautifully smooth surface lets it slip in smoothly to massage the prostate. The ring is just the right size for a bigger, more sensitive erection and, for me, a rapid orgasm. The ring and plug are just the right distance apart if the ring is fitted correctly."

Buy it here

Lovehoney Rotating Prostate Massager

Lovehoney High Roller Remote Control Rotating Prostate Massager
(319)
$49.99 $79.99 You save: $30.00 (38%)

Shaped especially to target the prostate, this massager is a bit larger than the average butt plug, but adds a remote control into the mix for ease of use. Try wearing it like a plug and sitting on it, using the remote to control the functions.

What customers say: "This thing is wild. Feels great on first insertion thanks to the bulb at the top and the tapering girth. It feels a lot more secure inside than other anal toys, and it doesn't slip out with your contractions like some toys can. P-spot massaging function is nothing short of amazing. The circular motion may not be for all users, but the intensity of the vibration is great and it wasn't too difficult to position it just right."

Buy it here

Types of Butt Plug

Vibrating Butt Plugs

32638_a22772_purple_003

Vibrating butt plugs are exactly what they sound like: butt plugs with the benefit of vibration. Vibrations provide additional sensations on top of the filled-up feeling butt plugs tend to provide, which many people find pleasureable.

VIbrating plugs may have wireless or wired remote controls, and some of the higher end ones can even be controlled long-distance via free apps on your phone. They're one of the best ways to share anal play with your partner.

Tail Butt Plugs

68132_a36838_silver_003

Tail butt plugs are the perfect way to add a little realism to your roleplay. These plugs feature long, often fluffy, tails that dangle outside your body, giving you a swishy tail. Common choices are pony tail butt plugs and bunny tail butt plugs.

Combining the satisfaction of a plug with the skin-teasing delight of a tail trailing across your skin is a surefire way to create fireworks in the bedroom.

Inflatable Butt Plugs

85158_a47583_black_002

Inflatable butt plugs are some of the most versatile plugs you can get. Thanks to their shape-changing abilities, they can grow in size from an average, respectable plug to an amazingly fulfilling plug as large as you can imagine.

Many people enjoy using them as warm-up because there's so much fine control over the size of the plug after it's inserted.

Jewelled Butt Plugs

73770_a40367_silver_003

Always popular, jewelled butt plugs add a little bling to your booty. Coming in a wide variety of shapes, sizes and materials, there are beautiful butt gems to be found at all anal experience levels.

When you look good, you feel good and that's the guiding principle behind jewelled butt plugs (besides the fact that, of course, they feel pretty darn good anyway!).

More Sexual Happiness Advice

LH-Forum-Card1-Desktop-566x566
The Lovehoney Forum
The best place on the internet to discuss all things sex and sex toys
LH-Blog-Card1-Desktop-566x566
Lovehoney Blog
Home of our famous Position of the Week series and more musings on sex and sexual happiness
LH-Youtube-Card1-Desktop-566x566
Lovehoney on YouTube
Discover hundreds of videos on dozens of different subjects, all presented by our in-house sexperts